
A moist, bulky breakfast treat, this muffin looks nothing like the recipe publisher's photo.
A few weeks ago, my sister-in-law emailed me this recipe from Self magazine for Banana Blueberry Muffins. I love bananas. I love blueberries. So I thought these would be yummy. I also thought they’d make a tasty housewarming treat for my other sister-in-law.
Flavorwise, they are tasty — the sweetness of the banana helps balance the tartness of my fresh, plump Jersey blueberries. And the orange zest adds a nice bit of complexity to the flavor. But the texture is all wrong: The predominance of banana & wet ingredients made for overly moist, almost mushy muffins. A firmer muffin texture would have helped balance the juiciness of the blueberries. Instead, these muffins are all mush & gush. The oat bran adds the only bit of “complication” to the texture — a subtle “grittiness” that I enjoy. (What’s the positive way to say something is “gritty”??)
My major complaint is that the recipe could have done more to guide the baker in what kind of muffin to expect and how to make it the best muffin it could be. First of all, take another look at the muffin they have pictured with the recipe — now banish that from your thoughts. My picture above is what these muffins look like. It’s actually more of a Banana Blueberry Bran Muffin, but I guess that was too long, less sexy of a name???
Secondly, many muffin recipes suggest serving warm, straight out of the oven. I tried to test these muffins about 30 or so minutes after I pulled them from the oven, and it was a bad scene. Although they had cleanly passed the toothpick test, when I tried to unwrap one from its pretty paper liner (which I used since I was intending them as gifts), I lost about 1/2 my muffin!! Not cool! But this morning, the muffins had firmed up and unwrapped from the liners with ease. I’m not sure if cooking them longer or directly in the muffin pan (sans liners) would have helped firm them up for immediate eating, but to be safe I will let them rest several hours before testing them next time.
Another flaw in the recipe is the number of servings. The recipe says it will make 6 muffins, but doesn’t call for an oversized or special muffin pan. So I used my standard muffin pan, and since it has 12 muffin cups, I doubled the recipe. Somehow I ended up with 21 muffins! Not a big deal, really, especially when you consider that the 6-muffin recipe claimed to come in at 130 calories per muffin. By my calculations, my “double batch” of 21 muffins have about 75 calories per muffin — and 2 of them were more than filling for breakfast this morning.
At the end of the day, I learned two big, important lessons by making these muffins: #1) Thoroughly consider your recipe. Alot of the problems I had with these muffins came from putting too much faith in the recipe (or the recipe’s publisher maybe?). Foremost, as I already mentioned, this recipe calls for very little in the way of dry ingredients; and oat bran makes up more than 1/2 of what little dry is called for. That makes for an extra moist muffin, which has its own set of considerations, as well as a very healthy, but somewhat gritty, fiber-filled muffin. Yummy to some. Regularity to others.
Which brings me to lesson #2) Consider your audience. As a writer, my audience is always looming, goading, encouraging, ignoring, whatever. As a baker, I tend to get wrapped up in the challenge of the tasty treat and, at least sometimes, give less forethought to who will be eating those treats and if they will indeed find them to be tasty. Especially if your “treat” includes a full-day’s serving of fiber! As my husband says, Nobody wants a colon blow as a gift. Doh!!
So, when it comes to gifting, go with a solid, steady favorite — an all-around winner. Not an experiment! Not a recipe you’ve never looked at or with ingredients (oat bran, in this case) you’ve never used. As it turns out, we’ll be keeping these for ourselves, and I’ll be making a batch of nice, classic blueberry muffins for my sister-in-law. I’ve made them before & they’re wonderful. A real crowd pleaser.